When a corporation pays its owners, the deduction depends on what the company’s own records show, not on what the owners report on their personal returns. That is the main owner pay lesson from Glass Warehouse, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-111, filed November 2, 2026. The Tax Court denied a $118,302 deduction for “subcontractor fees” because the company had no contracts, invoices, Forms 1099 or other records to support it, and upheld a 20% accuracy-related penalty for an earlier year.
What Happened in Glass Warehouse?
The taxpayer was a closely held C corporation with $4.1 million of gross receipts for its tax year ending June 30, 2019. Two married shareholder-officers owned it 80% and 20%, and both worked in the business full time, running sales, inventory purchasing, employees and customers. The company had about ten employees.
For that 2019 tax year, the court’s findings show three different pictures of owner pay:
- Line 12 of the Form 1120 reported $71,250 of officer compensation ($35,625 each on Form 1125-E).
- Forms W-2 reported wages of $92,712 and $73,962 to the two officers.
- The company also deducted $173,974 of subcontractor fees, which, the court said, presumably included $109,819 paid to the two owners. No Forms 1099 were issued for those amounts.
The IRS disallowed $118,302 of the subcontractor deduction for lack of substantiation. The court agreed. It found no testimony or other evidence about “the nature, contractual agreement, amount, or provider” of the claimed services, and no “business records, payroll records, contracts, invoices, Forms 1099, or other reliable documents.” The only testimony described the owners’ normal day-to-day management work.
Why Didn’t the Owners’ Personal Returns Help?
The owners reported the $109,819 as “Other income” on their joint return and paid employment taxes on it. The company argued that this proved the expense. The court disagreed: a corporation is a taxpayer separate from its shareholders, so “how a shareholder reports an item on a personal tax return does not control how the corporation reports that same item on its own tax return.”
The court also rejected an argument that section 3509, which covers employment tax liability when an employer treats an employee as a non-employee, turned the payments into deductible wages. It noted there was no evidence the officers had been misclassified.
The court did not decide whether the payments were really compensation or disguised dividends. It said it expressed “no view on the proper characterization of the payments,” because the deduction failed on substantiation alone. It mentioned bookkeeping entries that reclassified shareholder distributions as contract labor, but said it did not rely on them.
Why Was There Still a Penalty When a CPA Prepared the Return?
For the tax year ending June 30, 2018, the parties settled the tax issues, leaving only the penalty. The return showed $92,775 of tax against $107,775 required, a substantial understatement, so the court upheld the 20% penalty under section 6662(a). (The IRS conceded the penalty for the 2019 year.)
The company argued it relied on a professional preparer. The record had no evidence of what information the company gave its preparer or what advice it received. The court put it plainly: “Simply hiring a tax preparer does not insulate a taxpayer from the consequences of the tax positions on its return.” Reliance on an adviser can be reasonable cause, but only if you can show you gave the adviser complete, accurate information and actually relied on the advice in good faith.
What Does the IRS Say About Paying Yourself?
The IRS Paying yourself page lays out the basic rules for owners:
- A corporate officer who performs services is generally an employee, and wages should be “commensurate with your duties.”
- You “cannot designate a worker, including yourself, as an employee or independent contractor solely by the issuance of Form W-2 … or Form 1099-NEC.” The facts of the relationship control.
- Treating an employee, including yourself as a corporate officer, as a non-employee can make the business liable for employment taxes and possibly the trust fund recovery penalty.
- A loan from the corporation to an officer should look like an arm’s-length loan: a contract with a stated interest rate, a set repayment period and a consequence for not repaying. Collateral also points to a real loan.
- A distribution to shareholders from earnings and profits is generally a dividend, unless it is a return of capital.
- Partners are not employees of their partnership. They receive a Schedule K-1, not a Form W-2.
S corporation owners face a related issue. The IRS S corporation employees, shareholders and corporate officers page explains that payments to officers for services are wages, even when the officer is also a shareholder. If an S corporation shareholder who provides services receives cash or property, the corporation must determine and report a reasonable salary for that shareholder. For S corporations, wages paid can also affect the qualified business income deduction, which we cover in our post on QBI W-2 wages.
What Should Owners Document Before Year-End?
Glass Warehouse is a records case. As with West v. Commissioner, the outcome turned on documents the business never created. Before December 31, use this checklist for owner pay:
- Decide how each owner is paid. Write down whether each payment is wages, a distribution, a loan or a payment for separate services, and why.
- Run owner wages through payroll. Withhold and deposit payroll taxes, and confirm year-end W-2 amounts match payroll records.
- Reconcile officer compensation. Make sure the officer compensation on the return (Form 1125-E, where required) agrees with payroll and the general ledger.
- Paper any separate services. If an owner really provides services outside the normal officer role, put a written agreement in place, keep invoices and issue the required information returns.
- Document shareholder loans. Keep a signed note with a stated interest rate and repayment terms, and record the repayments.
- Review reclassification entries. Any entry moving amounts between distributions, wages and contract labor should have a clear, dated explanation.
- Keep records of what you gave your preparer. Keep copies of the information and questions you sent your tax adviser, and the answers you received.
- Run a projection. A year-end tax projection shows how owner pay choices affect both the business and personal returns. Our 2026 year-end planning checklist covers other December items.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a corporation pay an owner as a contractor instead of through payroll?
Only if the facts support it. The IRS says a Form W-2 or Form 1099-NEC alone does not decide worker status. An officer doing day-to-day management is generally an employee.
If I paid tax on the income personally, can the company still lose the deduction?
Yes. In Glass Warehouse, the owners reported the payments and paid employment taxes, but the corporation still lost the deduction because it could not substantiate the expense on its own.
Does using a CPA protect me from penalties?
Not by itself. You need to show you gave the preparer complete, accurate information and relied on the advice in good faith.
This post is general information, not individual tax advice. Contact us to discuss your situation.
Sources
- U.S. Tax Court: Glass Warehouse, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-111, Docket No. 23707-22 (Nov. 2, 2026)
- IRS: Paying yourself
- IRS: S corporation employees, shareholders and corporate officers
How Peters Bandura, LLC Can Help
From our Birmingham office, Peters Bandura, LLC helps closely held Alabama businesses set up owner pay, payroll and bookkeeping that hold up under review. If you want ongoing help, our outsourced CFO service keeps owner compensation, loans and distributions documented all year. Call us at (205) 547-0762 or request a consultation.
